Business Advisory

When Not to Hire

“Hire in haste, repent at leisure” or “be slow to hire and quick to fire”: this wisdom on hiring is often ignored by companies when they lose a key finance team member. The immediate reflex is to contact internal and external recruiting resources with the objective of identifying a replacement immediately. This is a mistake, and it virtually always comes with a substantial cost that is invisible to executives.

The Problem With Rapid Replacements

The world, and every industry we know that has a future, is changing at a rapid and accelerating rate. So are the reporting and analytical needs of every company. And so are the available tools with which to do the work. So the position description for a newly vacated role should have evolved significantly since the last incumbent was hired. Failing to capture this evolution through an intentional recalibration process is a disservice to the company and anyone who gets hired into the role.

  • What if the workload of a position that previously required 50 hours a week to complete can be reduced to 15 through the application of available, already owned technology?
  • What if 80% of the reporting or analytical product coming from this role is NEVER reviewed or never integrated into decision making by the recipients?
  • What if finance group clients—manufacturing, distribution, logistics, marketing, sales, customer service—NEED and WANT specific analysis to manage their business but finance bandwidth is occupied with work that goes unread?

And NONE of this, by the way, is the fault of the departing/transferred/promoted employee or executive. Most finance teams are staffed at survival level, and time to be introspective about work content and relevance is in short supply.

The Solution and Getting Support

The time to get these questions answered and to operate on them is immediately after the departure or transfer event becomes known. And the good news is it can be done as part of the relatively standard practice of bringing in an outside project resource to gap the role. For this to be successful, however, there needs to be alignment (not conflict) between the company’s interests and the individual deployed to complete what should in fact be a structured project. That is another example of where the so called “contingent” consulting model that is so prevalent in this market does not work. We have a process for this, and it’s very straightforward.

The alternative carries huge risks and missed opportunity and is a disservice to whoever you hire into the role.

One potential outcome: they arrive, realize they can do the work in 15 hours a week, but because they left a job to join you, they are put into the untenable position of risking their livelihood if they tell you. So they generally won’t, the new hire will be disappointed or bored, early turnover may result and opportunity will be missed.

If you would like to make the most of the opportunity presented by an employee promotion or departure, please contact us. You can also learn more about how we can offer support on our Interim Financial Management services page or by downloading our general service sheet below:

financial consulting firm california

About the Author

David Lewis has been the CEO or founding partner of 5 companies, one a 600-person family business, three successful startups in the areas of executive search, consulting and financial project execution, as well as a venture-capital-backed software development firm. His last startup scaled to a 300-person consulting and executive services firm in seven and a half years. During his tenure, the firm worked with companies ranging from Fortune 500 companies to venture-backed startups. He has deep functional expertise in creation and implementation of accountability systems, planning, finance, talent acquisition and development and key executive coaching. David holds Bachelors and Masters degrees in Economics from Georgetown University in Washington DC.

Categorized in: ,

similar articles

Learn to think and approach problems like our financial consultants.

Financial Reporting & Accounting

Finance & Accounting Process Optimization and More Through ESOAR (Part 2)

Once a standardized process has been successfully implemented, efforts can shift towards finance & accounting process Optimization, Automation and Robotization to derive further value.

July 28, 2021Justin Vu

Resources

Accounting Process Improvement Strategies Guide

Get our comprehensive guide to using the ESOAR methodology to improve accounting processes within your organization. This guide also includes a detailed example of an accounting department improving its Provision for Sales Returns process.

George Jacob

Financial Reporting & Accounting

How to Improve Accounting Processes Using ESOAR (Part 1)

Want to know how to improve accounting processes? You might take advantage of ESOAR, a process improvement methodology that can help you drive long-term value. This post covers Elimination and Standardization stages of the methodology.

July 22, 2021Justin Vu

See All

Back to Insights